Banner

New podcast / Classifieds / Other Cities
Guangzhou
Shenzhen

Shanghai's Nazis: The Good Nazi
Print
Features
Monday, 27 April 2009 09:04
Written by JFK Miller
The Good Nazi
Party loyalist John Rabe helped save 250,000 Chinese from the Japanese


"If I had not seen it with my own eyes, I would not have believed it.” So wrote John Rabe, a German Nazi, in the diary he kept of the atrocities he witnessed in the Rape of Nanking.

Rabe was an Old China Hand by the time the Japanese invaded Nanking, then China’s capital, in December 1937. Born in Hamburg, Rabe came to China in 1908 aged 26, and became Siemens’ ‘man in China’ in 1910, working in various cities, including Shanghai. From 1931 to 1938, he was Siemens’ representative in Nanking, now called Nanjing.

After Shanghai fell to the Japanese, Germany’s ally in the war, Rabe and a handful of other foreigners established the ‘Nanking Safety Zone,’ a demilitarized area in the western part of the city, to shelter Chinese civilians. Although Japanese soldiers continued to breach the zone and commit atrocities therein, they generally honored its neutrality, but only because of Rabe’s continued intercessions. Rabe and his group helped save an estimated 200,000 to 250,000 Chinese from the massacre. At one point, he sheltered some 600 Chinese in his own house, which he protected by hanging an enormous swastika outside as an ‘off limits’ sign to the Japanese. Rabe’s heroism was straightforward: “You simply do what must be done,” he wrote.

Click here to read on...

The Good Nazi
Party loyalist John Rabe helped save 250,000 Chinese from the Japanese


"If I had not seen it with my own eyes, I would not have believed it.” So wrote John Rabe, a German Nazi, in the diary he kept of the atrocities he witnessed in the Rape of Nanking.

 
John Rabe - The Movie
Rabe may be known as the ‘Schindler of China’ but this film biog is no Schindler’s List

The laudable, valorous John Rabe - a hero to both Chinese and Germans; a man who risked his own life to save hundreds of thousands of innocent victims from certain death; a person who wore the badge of National Socialism but nonetheless acted out of human decency; a character who, despite his epic heroism, died in obscure poverty… how could the filmmakers turn such sensational material into one almighty luftnummer?

German actor Ulrich Tukur, familiar to Western audiences from The Lives of Others (2006) in which he played a slimy, menacing Stasi bureaucrat, gets to play the good guy this time. And he does a decent job, too. His portrayal of John Rabe is thoughtful and understated – exactly what the role required – but even his capable performance and the movie’s lavish production values aren’t enough to elevate it from the realm of melodrama.

“It’s taken more than 70 years for John Rabe to get the recognition he deserves,” said writer-director Florian Gallenberger at the movie’s premiere earlier this year.

We agree, but Rabe deserves better than this.

China release date: April 29
 
Rabe was an Old China Hand by the time the Japanese invaded Nanking, then China’s capital, in December 1937. Born in Hamburg, Rabe came to China in 1908 aged 26, and became Siemens’ ‘man in China’ in 1910, working in various cities, including Shanghai. From 1931 to 1938, he was Siemens’ representative in Nanking, now called Nanjing.

After Shanghai fell to the Japanese, Germany’s ally in the war, Rabe and a handful of other foreigners established the ‘Nanking Safety Zone,’ a demilitarized area in the western part of the city, to shelter Chinese civilians. Although Japanese soldiers continued to breach the zone and commit atrocities therein, they generally honored its neutrality, but only because of Rabe’s continued intercessions. Rabe and his group helped save an estimated 200,000 to 250,000 Chinese from the massacre. At one point, he sheltered some 600 Chinese in his own house, which he protected by hanging an enormous swastika outside as an ‘off limits’ sign to the Japanese. Rabe’s heroism was straightforward: “You simply do what must be done,” he wrote.

Throughout his 2,600-page diary, Rabe detailed the rape, torture, mutilation and murder committed by the Japanese army against innocent Chinese. It is estimated that as many as 300,000 Chinese were slaughtered during the six-week killing spree.

Rabe could so easily have fled Nanking like many other foreigners, but he stayed to protect his Chinese staff and co-workers. “I cannot bring myself for now to betray the trust these people have put in me,” he wrote. In February 1938, while the massacre was still continuing, Rabe travelled to Germany, to alert the Nazi high command of the genocide. But after sending Hitler the information, including photographs and an amateur film of the atrocities, Rabe was arrested and interrogated by the Gestapo and forbidden to raise the matter again.

After the war, Rabe was denounced by the Allies for his Nazi party membership. Although he was eventually cleared of any wrongdoing, the trial took a toll on his health and savings and he died in poverty in Berlin in 1950.

“Rabe was a kind of Oscar Schindler, but in Nanjing,” says Frank Hollmann, Shanghai Correspondent of Main-Post, a German daily newspaper. “Yes, he was a Nazi. But what you have to understand is that he joined the party at a time when it was seen as a kind of national resurrection of Germany. Although Rabe was totally admiring of Hitler, from the beginning of the movement he hadn’t been in Germany, so all he could know about the Nazis was from some news clips in a time without Internet and television and so on.”

For more stories on Nazis in Shanghai, click on these links:


Comments (1)Add Comment
...
written by Jakob Montrasio, April 29, 2009
I've worked on the movie here in Shanghai but didn't see it yet. All the reviews so far have been more or less positive... Why is it a Luftnummer? Lavish production values? It won a couple of awards already. Did you even see it? smilies/smiley.gif

I'll get my own opinion on the weekend, when it finally starts here...

Write comment

busy
 

Shanghai Time Machine!

I'd set the clock and teleport to...

Banner

that's Shanghai E-magazine

THAT'S SHANGHAI!
E-MAGAZINE
View the August 2010 interactive issue of That's Shanghai online!

RELATED CONTENT

Diving into Atlantis
that’s Shanghai explores the secret underwater city below Qiandao LakeApparently, w  ... more »
Japanese eats
When looking for Japanese food in Shanghai, forget the RMB100 all-you-can-eat sushi r  ... more »
Papua New Guinea's Kokoda Trail
Papua New Guinea’s Kokoda Trail is one of Asia’s most grueling - and life-threat  ... more »
A Most Immoral Woman with Linda Jaivin
Urbanatomy caught up with best-selling erotic novelist and China Hand Linda Jaivin to  ... more »
Banner